I wrote a few weeks ago about my friend Sharon introducing me to
Cloud City Coffee’s wonderful coconut bread. When I asked the barista if he would share the recipe with me, he smiled as though this was a common question, and then said “no.”
I couldn’t let the quest end there. Thoughts of this coconut bread wouldn’t leave me alone.
For Easter dinner, I made a coconut bread for dessert, adding flaked coconut to a basic pound cake recipe. Dense and boring, it was not as good as Cloud City’s.
I searched the internet. I found a like minded soul, over at
Tea & Cookies, who mused over the very same bread on her blog, in an entry titled "Coconut Bread, and a Mystery." She also asked Cloud City for the recipe. Her conversation went like this:
My neighbor said she once asked at the cafĂ© for the recipe but got the brush off. Never one to be discouraged, this week when I was in the neighborhood I popped in and asked—ever so sweetly—where the recipe came from. Was it from a cookbook, perhaps?
“Nah, the owner got it from someone she knows,” the guy behind the counter told me. “She had to trade some recipes for it and promise never, ever to give it to anyone else.”
“She has to take it to the grave with her?” I asked, partially joking but not really.
“Yeah, something like that.”
I realized then that no amount of visits to Cloud City was going to bag me that recipe. I would have to come up with my own. Here is what I could tell for sure: it contains coconut and walnuts and seems to be glazed.

I browsed through my cookbooks to gather some ideas. I followed some of the leads from the other blogger’s comment section about the bread. I searched through the recipes of some of my favorite blogs. After looking over dozens of recipes, I set about making my plan.
There were a few basic methods to try. There is the
Gourmet Magazine pound cake method, apparently Elvis’ favorite recipe, that requires more than 10 minutes of beating and no rising agent (baking powder or baking soda). Then, there is the
Cooks Illustrated method of melted butter and a food processor. And of course, there is just the straight-forward method of beating together the butter and sugar and mixing in the remaining ingredients.
Next, I looked at the varying ratios of wet to dry ingredients. I also came up with a list of potential ideas for ensuring a really moist loaf. My list included milk, cream, coconut milk, yogurt, sour cream, and cream cheese.
After reviewing all of the ideas that I had collected, I wrote out four different recipes, each one a different combination of ideas, and headed to the kitchen.
- My first loaf used the Gourmet recipe’s method of prolonged beating, and added coconut milk to enhance the flavor of the flaked coconut.
- My second loaf used the Cooks Illustrated food processor method with melted butter. I used sour cream as an added wet ingredient.
- My third loaf also used the Cooks Illustrated food processor method. This time I used full fat plain yogurt instead of sour cream.
- My fourth loaf, adapted from a recipe posted in the comment section of the Tea & Cookies post, used much eggs than the other loaves, and had the addition of coconut milk as one of the wet ingredients. The original posted recipe called for milk instead of coconut milk.
I applied a glaze to all of the loaves, gently melting ½ cup of sugar in 2 tablespoons of milk. When the loaves were cool, I poured the glaze over each one.
Now it was time for a coconut bread tasting! We had five expert tasters (and by expert, I mean, each one of them has been eating food for a very long time). I cut up the four loaves and anonymously plated them. I also cut and plated a piece of Cloud City’s bread, and threw it on the tasting line. Each taster assigned a “first place” and “second place” to their top two favorites. I am confident but not arrogant! I wanted to be sure that if Cloud City’s came in first (the most likely event), that I would still have a “winning” recipe that I could make at home.

As I predicted, Cloud City Coffee's coconut bread netted the Gold Ribbon, confirming its position as Best Coconut Bread in the World! A very close second place, for the Silver Ribbon, was recipe #4. My sister wavered between the two, eventually putting Cloud City in first place for flavor, but wishing that it had the slightly more moist texture of Recipe #4. Interestingly, both male tasters choose the recipe #4 as the winner and the placed Cloud City’s in second place.
Something dawned on me when I got home later that evening. The two winning breads, the actual Cloud City loaf, and the recipe found amongst the Tea & Cookies comments, were very similar. I went back to the blog and read the comment section again. There it was, the recipe I had altered into my "Recipe #4," along with a little note, from "Denise."
"Denise said... I've spent considerable time here reading your log and living vicariously through your words. In exchange for the much-needed virtual travel, I think it's only fair that I share the coconut loaf recipe I've prepared for a few years. Thank you for taking me/us along with you on your journeys."
There was something about the way that she wrote about it being "only fair" to share her recipe. I started to wonder, this Denise, with no last name and no hyperlink to her name, who is she? Could she be connected to Cloud City Coffee? Could she be the anonymous friend who shared the original recipe and swore the baker to secrecy?
I emailed the Tea & Cookies blogger and asked her if she ever netted the real recipe for herself. "No," she said, "but let me know if you perfect it." Is it possible the "real" recipe has been RIGHT UNDER HER NOSE this whole time? I guess I have my own "Coconut Bread, and a Mystery."
Adapted from the mysterious "Denise's” Coconut Loaf recipe
1/2 lb. (2 sticks) butter (room temperature)
1 cup sugar
2 large eggs (room temperature)
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
2 cups unbleached, all-purpose flour
2 teaspoon baking powder
1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
3/4 cup milk (or coconut milk)
1 cup flaked coconut
1/4 cup chopped walnuts
1 cup powdered sugar
3 tablespoons milk
Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Cut a piece of parchment paper, 9 inches wide, to fit the inside of a 9 x 5 x 3 loaf pan. Lightly butter the parchment paper and line the loaf pan, butter side up.
Beat the butter and sugar together for two minutes. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating for about 10 seconds after each addition. Add the vanilla.
In a separate bowl, stir together flour, baking powder and salt. Add half of the flour mixture to the beaten butter and sugar, mix well. Add the milk, continuing to mix. Add the remaining flour mixture. Stir in the coconut and walnuts until just combined.
Pour into the prepared pan. Bake for 1 hour or until a cake tester comes out clean. You can use a knife, wooden skewer, or toothpick to test the loaf. It doesn't have to be bone-dry, but shouldn't have any wet crumbs clinging to the tester. Cool for 10 minutes in pan, then remove to a wire rack to cool completely.
Combine remaining 1 cup of powdered sugar and 3 tablespoons of milk. Pour over completely cooled cake.
Keep, unrefrigerated, for up to 4 days, if it lasts that long!
UPDATE: For the REAL Cloud City Recipe... click here!